ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon. ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background. Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting. Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle. Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff. ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison. ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.
ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background.
 Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting.
 Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle.
 Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison.
ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.
ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon. ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background.
 Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting.
 Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle.
 Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison.
ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.

New Moon Multichrome Shadow Stix

It's Always Been Him

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
3,399 Reviews

It's Always Been Him - pinky copper to gold to green

🌱 Vegan
🐰 Cruelty-free
🍄 Colour-shifting
🎨 Ultra-pigmented
🍦 Super creamy
🍄 Colour-shifting
🌈 Multichrome finish
💅 Limited edition

review

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 3,399 reviews
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
3,399 reviews
  • Shawna P.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    So Into U
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6/12/26
    Great!

    Love this eyeshadow stick! Great quality! Beautiful colour!

    Was this helpful?
  • Kelly S.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Wolf Girl
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6/11/26
    So many compliments!

    I get so many compliments wearing these! Throw a little liquid eyeliner on and done. Plus the cost is amazing. I went back and bought a second wolf girl and a vampire girl to boot.

    Was this helpful?
  • Katie E.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Essential Neutrals
    I recommend this product
    Rated 4 out of 5 stars
    6/11/26
    This trio

    It goes on smooth and is nice but I don't like how it blends for my hooded eyes. It would probably work better for non hooded eyes.

    Was this helpful?
  • Carrema T.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Bare With Me
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6/10/26
    Love

    It’s a dupe for About Face. Love it

    Was this helpful?
  • Mel B.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Disco Disco
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    6/9/26
    She cute!

    Girl, you stunning! She'll transform you into That Girl the second you swipe her on. You need her!

    Was this helpful?