ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon. ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background. Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting. Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle. Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff. ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison. ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.
ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background.
 Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting.
 Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle.
 Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison.
ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.
ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon. ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background.
 Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting.
 Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle.
 Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison.
ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.

New Moon Multichrome Shadow Stix

Creamy Eyeshadow Stick

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
3,113 Reviews

It's Always Been Him - pinky copper to gold to green

🌱 Vegan
🐰 Cruelty-free
🍄 Colour-shifting
🎨 Ultra-pigmented
🍦 Super creamy
🍄 Colour-shifting
🌈 Multichrome finish
💅 Limited edition

review

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 3,113 reviews
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
3,113 reviews
  • Sarah R.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cotton Candy
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/5/26
    Subtle, pretty and buildable.

    This is a very pretty color shifting eyeshadow stick, nice smooth formula that can be blended thin or built up. I have extremely sensitive eyes, and Colourpop's cosmetics never irritate them at all. These sticks are so easy to use, and very wearable for being such cute cotton candy colors.

    Was this helpful?
  • AnnaLyssa Y.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Disco Disco
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/5/26
    Stunning shift

    Beautiful color shift, love the icy blue for my inner corner! The pencil glides so smoothly!

    Was this helpful?
  • Erika H.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Disco Disco
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/4/26
    Subtle but fun!

    I like to use a shimmery shadow on the inner corners of my eyes and this was a fun change of color for me! It's not a super bright "color" which is exactly what I was hoping, but the shine and pinky teal blue color shift are super unique and fun. Love the easy stick application.

    Was this helpful?
  • kay
    Verified Reviewer
    Reviewing
    Next Spot
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/3/26
    loving the plum bronze!

    I'm completely obsessed with this shade!! I have medium brown skin and favor bronzey shades, and this is literally gorgeous on me! "Plum bronze" is the perfect descriptor for this color-- it has a distinct pink tint to it, but the shade itself is on the cooler purple side, and yet it remains a classy bronze! Application is very smooth and light, too, and it lasts a long time (though it might wear slightly from your crease after a few hours, I haven't found the effect too noticeable)!

    Was this helpful?
  • Sofia S. J.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cotton Candy
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/2/26
    I love it

    I love the colour and it is so creamy. Goes on easily.

    Was this helpful?