ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon. ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background. Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting. Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle. Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff. ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison. ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.
ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background.
 Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting.
 Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle.
 Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison.
ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.
ColourPop Shadow Stix 'It’s Always Been Him' stands uncapped, revealing a shimmery green multichrome tip on a black twist-up stick with gold lettering, beside its box on a rock, framed by pine trees and a glowing full moon. ColourPop Shadow Stix “It’s Always Been Him” swatched in a thick diagonal swipe, showing a metallic duochrome copper-rose base with a vivid green shift and fine shimmer on a white background.
 Multichrome eyeshadow shifts olive green to rosy copper on a single eyelid, showcasing It’s Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix, delivering smooth metallic payoff with a precise swipe, captured in a close-up under studio lighting.
 Close-up eyelid showcasing It's Always Been Him Shadow Stix, a ColourPop Shadow Stix shade, with multichrome pink, green, and gold metallic shimmer sweeping across the lid and crease on a brown eye, smoothly blended with fine sparkle.
 Shimmering eyelid wears Love Triangle ColourPop Shadow Stix, shifting pink‑green‑gold across the lid in a metallic multichrome finish; extreme close-up of one eye with natural lashes and brow showing color payoff.
 ColourPop Shadow Stix in Wolf Girl swatched on three arms (light, medium, deep); top stripe shifts green to gold-orange. Lower stripes show It’s Always Been Him (peachy pink with teal shift) and Vampire Girl (red with green shift) for comparison.
ColourPop Shadow Stix in It’s Always Been Him stands uncapped to reveal a multichrome green‑gold‑pink shimmer tip, with the black “the twilight saga new moon” tube beside its matching illustrated box and cap on a clean white background.

New Moon Multichrome Shadow Stix

Creamy Eyeshadow Stick

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
3,138 Reviews

It's Always Been Him - pinky copper to gold to green

🌱 Vegan
🐰 Cruelty-free
🍄 Colour-shifting
🎨 Ultra-pigmented
🍦 Super creamy
🍄 Colour-shifting
🌈 Multichrome finish
💅 Limited edition

review

4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 3,138 reviews
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
3,138 reviews
  • Nicole G.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Friday Feels
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/15/26
    Pretty

    Such a pretty peachy pink color. Makes my blue eyes pop. Highly recommend for those with blue eyes or anyone who loves peachy eyeshadow!

    Was this helpful?
  • Yarrow M.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Game Over
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/15/26
    great coverage and staying power!

    i love this! i was skeptical since a lot of shadow sticks i've tried in the past would never set right and i'd always end up with creasing or patchy coverage. not this one though! it glides on very smooth, is blendable, and has amazing coverage with zero creasing on me. it stays put, too! the duo chrome shade game over is so freakin cute too. i love it as a highlighter at the corners of my eyes, under my lower lashes, or just covering my lids for a quick cutesy glam look. will be buying more

    Was this helpful?
  • Sydney B.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cold Girl
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/15/26
    Beautifully frosty

    Great cream shadow, love the delicate shimmering effect

    Was this helpful?
  • Sydney B.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Bare With Me
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/15/26
    Smells and looks gorgeous!

    Perfect everyday tint and thank the heavens it smells and tastes nice. So many products are gross. This looks natural and is softening.

    Was this helpful?
  • Bobbie A.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Bare With Me
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1/15/26
    Perfect nude

    Went on smooth and set well under powder shadow.

    Was this helpful?